So Ryan Giggs turned forty today. Hats off to the great man whose career has spanned three separate decades, in which time he has won everything numerous times and become United's highest appearance maker.
The man is a great player. He is the (despite recent super-injunctiongate furores) consummate professional, keeping his head down, eating correctly, drinking correctly and training sensibly. He still has an insatiable hunger for the game. These factors reveal the key to his longevity.
But the question remains... is he the best player the Premiership has seen? Er, no. Not by a long way I'm afraid. If the test was based on loyalty and longevity then yes, Giggs would win hands down. However, I base my opinions on 'the best' by who can alter a game, and who can alter the fortunes of a club. Cantona being one. When he came to United yes, fair enough they were already a top 3 club, but they hadn't won the title for 26 years. Cantona galvanised the team, the fans and the club and lifted them into the top position. Thierry Henry could change a game with his pace, vision and lightning quick brain. I was always worried when United faced Arsenal with Henry in the team, knowing he could be the difference. I would argue Peter Schmeichel used to win United at least 10 points per season with his incredible saves.
Don't get me wrong I completely agree Giggs is and was a great player. He burst onto the scene in the early nineties, and I think they are still trying to untie the legs of the full backs he twisted into all shapes. As he got older he was able to develop his game from a flying winger into a ball playing midfield controller. However, pundits always cite his loyalty to the Manchester United, and yes that is undoubted. But I feel it is alot easier to be loyal to a club like Manchester United who are constantly winning trophies, than it would be to be loyal to be for a 'lesser' club like Stoke for example. Would Giggs have been as loyal if he had started at say Everton? Like hell he would.
Forgive me if this sounds like Ryan bashing. I assure you it's not- he has been one of my favourite United players since I began supporting the club. I just think it is important to get some perspective here. When someone reaches a milestone the media do tend to have a head freeze and start rolling out the awards willy nilly. The fact that Giggs is a great player is never in doubt. He will be remembered as one of United's greatest servants. But the best player ever in the Premier League? Do me a favour.